PB's Online Classroom, where we get down with American Lit.
1.23.2009
"Will faithfully execute," or "will execute faithfully"?
Chief Justice Roberts' flub of the Oath of Office at Tuesday's inauguration has been attributed to his grammar hang up. Read about it in the New York Times: "Oaf of Office."
One: Most things in literature are intentional. Even when this may not seem to be the case, it very well may be. That said, not all things mean more than what they initially seem. But again, it might. Sometimes water is just water. Other times, though, water is not just water, it's the Ocean of Notions, or the Dull Lake.Take Away: As readers, we must assume that writers are smart, know what they’re doing, and have done so with intention.
Addendum A: Rain usually means something. Always. (But not always the same thing.)
Addendum B: Names do, too. Like Esperanza, Tea Cake, Gatsby, and Daisy. Holden, too.
Addendum C: Trees always mean things, especially ones bearing fruit.
Addendum D: Mangoes and other exotic fruits always mean a very specific thing. But we’re not going to go there. Not yet…
Two: By indirection, find direction. Revision. Revision. Revision. A piece of writing is never completed, only abandoned. Take Away: Writing is a process. In other words, it's more a means than it is an end.
Three: Literature is full of contradictions, paradoxes, oxymorons, and ironies. So, too, is life. This doesn't make one thing right and the other thing wrong. Both can exist and be in simultaneous harmony and tension. Take away: Embrace multiple perspectives.
Four: Every interpretation is not correct. Without substantial textual support and a clearly articulated, rational analysis, an interpretation is only as good as a guess. Back up your opinion. Validate it. Take Away: Take us there--to the text, that is.
No comments:
Post a Comment